Who Sent This Email? How to Check the Real Sender

The name and address in the «From» line are written by whoever sends the message, and nothing stops a scammer from putting your bank's name there. What is much harder to fake is the evidence a message carries with it: whether the sender's domain signed it, which service sent it and where your reply would go. In this inbox you can see that evidence with one button, «Who sent this?», on any message you open. This guide explains what each line of the answer means and what to do with it.

Why the «From» line proves nothing

An email's «From» line works like the return address on an envelope: the sender fills it in, and the post office delivers the letter anyway. The display name is free text, and the address can be set to anything. That is why the mail world added three standard checks, which the receiving server runs when a message arrives:

Most mail apps run these checks quietly and only use the result to decide what goes to spam. Here you can see the result yourself.

How to check a message here

  1. Open the message in the inbox.
  2. Press «Who sent this?» in the panel above the message.
  3. Read the first line, the verdict, and then the details under it.

The check reads only the technical part of the message, not the text you see, and it sends nothing to the sender. Pressing the button does not tell anyone that you opened the message.

The three possible answers

«Confirmed: the sender's domain signed this message, and the signature checks out.»

The message really comes from the domain shown in «Sender's domain», and it was not changed on the way. Large services such as banks, shops, social networks and most senders of sign-up codes usually get this answer.

One thing «confirmed» does not mean: that the domain is the one you think it is. A scammer can register paypal-account-help.net and sign their own mail perfectly. The check confirms the domain, so read the domain itself, letter by letter.

«Warning: the sender's signature did not check out — this message may be forged.»

The message claims to come from a domain, but the evidence does not agree. It may be a forgery. It can also happen to honest mail that a mailing list changed on the way, for example by adding a footer or editing the subject. Either way, do not click its links or open its attachments. If it claims to come from a service you use, type that service's address into your browser yourself and check there.

«Not confirmed: the message has no signature from the sender's domain that our server could verify.»

There is nothing to confirm the sender with, but nothing to accuse them of either. This is common for small senders, old systems and some forum or website notifications. Treat links and attachments with care, and be especially careful if the message asks for a password or a payment.

The details, line by line

LineWhat it tells you
Sender's domainThe domain from the «From» line. Compare it with the service the message claims to be from.
Signed byThe domain or domains whose signature the message carries. A newsletter often has two: the company's and the mailing platform's. A signature being present is not the same as a signature that checks out; the verdict line tells you which it is.
Sent viaThe mailing platform or mail provider, when we recognise it: for example Mailchimp, SendGrid or Gmail. A «bank notice» sent through a free personal mailbox is a red flag.
Servers on the wayHow many mail servers passed the message along. A handful is normal for large services.
First serverThe oldest server recorded on the way. It often points to the sender's mail provider.
Replies will go to a different domainShown only when your reply would go somewhere other than the sender's domain. Some help desks work this way, but it is also a classic trick: a message «from» your bank whose replies go to an unrelated address.

Three examples of reading the answer

These are made-up examples of the kind of messages people receive, to show how the lines fit together.

What the check cannot do

The same panel also shows whether a message contains trackers; see how to tell if an email is tracking you.

Quick answers

Does pressing «Who sent this?» tell the sender anything?

No. The check uses information that is already inside the message. Nothing is sent to the sender, and no images are loaded by it.

Can I check a message from my own mailbox here?

Only messages that arrive in this inbox can be checked. In your own mail app, look for an option such as «Show original» or «View message source»: most apps show the same SPF, DKIM and DMARC results there, though in a less readable form.

Why does a newsletter show two signers?

The company signs with its own domain and the mailing platform adds its own signature too. That is normal. What matters is that the verdict line says «Confirmed».

Is a confirmed message always safe?

No. It only means the message really comes from the domain shown. Fraudsters can own domains too, which is why the domain name itself is the first thing to check.

Need an address to receive mail right now? The email generator gives you one as soon as the page opens.

← Kembali ke semua artikel